So Star Wars ep III is out today! Any of you guys see it yet? If so what do you think? Personally I am going to wait till monday to see it so its not too crowded. When looking it up here is what the critics said:

http://movies.yahoo.com/shop?d=hv&cf=criti...c&id=1808406061

Looks like it has an avrage of a B+ score with many of them saying its as good as Empire Strikes Back. God I hope they are right.

ill probly see it next week.


crowded movie theatres make me want to.. something, something... murder.. something, something...

Saw it.


meh... Better than the last two. Still, it was no 4,5 or 6

Pfft, you know how those hardcore star wars fans are... they'll hate anything.

Anyways, I thought it was pretty good. Sucks going in to watch it cuz you know everything that's going to happen tho.

I don't even know what to say about Episode III. The movie was ... AWESOME ... to say the least. The movie was done extremely well and the editing, oh, the editing was top notch. I'll stay away from discussing the movie until more people have seen it.

nerds

i loved it! :D saw it twice already. :wink:

I read the book, so I know what happens and shit. If the movie sticks to the dialogue, it will rock


Im dying to see Anakin acting out the struggle with himself


I dont see how the hardcore fans can say the first 3 movies were better. I always thot they were mediocre at best

The facination with the original trilogy has to do with the concept and story telling. The dialog and events were no different than what is happening in the prequels. People just don't realize that because they were a lot younger during the original trilogy so something being corny was accepted then. Now that people are older, they feel that they need some serious movie. ANH, ESB, ROTJ were far from that. Every film is a space opera.

I liked it. I'd give it a 7.5/10...maybe 8 in some parts...and the end after he gets off the operating table... <3 Even if it was a bit cliched, it still made me squirm in my seat...in a good way. =D

I swear to god they added digital affects to his cloak when he was on the bridge.

The PROBLEM I have always seen with the prequels...this one included, but not so much as the first two...is that the sound is all off. There's a lot of times where the music SHOULD be louder or swelling, and it doesn't...and there are a lot of times when it is too damn silent. It's like watching a movie with all the special affects but no sound. Like it's unfinished. The first three weren't like this at all...there was ALWAYS good sound...but the prequels...it makes a hell of a difference that you wouldn't realise. It makes some things seem corny when they aren't really.

I think they overdid Sidious a litte, too. Not his voice or his looks, but just...I don't know. He seems silly sometimes. Laughs too much. He didn't laugh quite so much when we see him in the originals, and his laugh is a bit...I dunno...more evil and less silly then. He just overdid the maniacal laughter, is all.

And I liked how he was faking with Windu. Poor Ani never stood a chance against those pleas.

And Padme...I don't think she did such good acting in this one. Some of it was really a bit off. She doesn't LOOK like a dying woman (oh what, you all know it's gonna happen). They could have done her makeup a hell of a lot better for a dying woman in pain, and she could have done way better acting.

Anyway. Hi.

OMG I love Vader. Helmet, cloak swirls, everything was hot. Between Sidious, Vader, and Voldemort, I'm a ball of giggling mass when it comes to evil overlords. And Snape, too. OMG Snape.

What.

Hell, I know Sarah agrees with me (as long as I add Luscious...I mean Lucius, to the list)!

sidious is more giddy and silly in this because he has just taken over and is believe it or not younger, 20 years from now he's got the galaxy under his thumb and has mellowed. padme wasnt supposed to look like a dying woman because there was nothing wrong with her physically.

Are you kidding me?

She just gave birth to twins!

NO WOMAN looks like that after giving birth to TWINS!!

...except for the ones in movies.

And I'm favouring that the lightning messed him up a little when it came to giggling. It like started immediately after he got zapped.

And is it just me...or did Chewie seem a bit...fat?


....maybe Han didn't take very good care of his Wookiee!

galactic steroid policy didnt go into affect for another 10 years

Chewie didn't come off as fat to me. Peter Mayhew played him in this movie as well and he's still very skinny.

Alright I'm not a Star Wars freak but I did read the books, mostly because I'll read anything I can get my hands on. And on the subject of Chewy, does anyone remember what Yoda called the wookie standing next to Chewy? I thought he might have said, "General Lum" but I dont know. In the books far after Return of the Jedi Chewbacca dies. Leia goes back to the planet of the Wookies (Kashiik I think it's spelled) and gets Chewbacca's cousin Lumbacca, who they immediately start calling Lumpy. I was wondering if that was him? And Chewy didn't look fat to me at all, sorry Sidd.

On the subject of Padme. She did just give birth to two babies...people who do not have a uterus are not allowed to comment on what a woman would look like after squeezing TWO things the size of watermelons out of something the size of a lemon. ^_^ I agree with Sidd, she would not have looked so damn pretty. There would have been sweat, tears and much more screaming. Take it from me, I have a uterus. =P

Lucius is way more evil than Vader! ^_^ And Voldemort could kick vaders ass anyday! Who needs a lightsaber when you have Avada Kedavra?

Ya, force choke! No wand business at all, no words, just sheer will.

And Jedi Mind Trick = Imperio, but can be done with good conscience, bwahaha

Force Lightning = Crucio with a sizzling bang

It all depends on if Vader can deflect or shrug off magic...hmm.

Many crossovers have attempted to answer that very question. I suppose we will never know.

It's like Trekkie vs. Warsie arguements. Of COURSE Star Wars people would win, they got faster, bigger, more powerful ships and resources Trekkie people could only dream to have. But Trekkies have damn Q and etc, and that's what puts them to the advantage.

I'm sorry but there's no way Vader would be beaten by someone who got punked by a half trained level 9 wizard.

then again...

vorpal bunnies > all

And if you're a girl and have never given birth, you can't comment on how bad child birth is either. :P

pwnet

You are slowly making me not like HP........

Yes, but we can have a pretty good idea.

Unless, Chimi, you were once a virgin girl.

I've seen childbirth first hand, I was the only one there when my cousin had her baby. IT WAS DISGUSTING, and it looked horribly painful. And again, I agree with Sidd, we have a much better idea about what childbirth would be like...because we both have a uterus, unlike Chimi...well we dont know that for sure but I suppose it's safe to assume. =D

Come on Kobe, HP is awesome! You're a not a real fan if you can just stop liking it =

No I am, but comparing it to SW like that, ugh


Sorry sidd.....

A mans job is just as hard as a womans in childbirth I hear. We have to sit there and get physically abused during it whial the woman screams how they hate us...

Not to mention the whole going to the store at 3 in the morining so you can get the woman pickles and peanut butter to satisfy her craving. Or how about the month or two with no sex we must endure during the last phases of pregency...

/shutter

Fuck that, my kid will have brain damage then, or holes in its skull

and yes, Im drunk again.....

Oh yes. You poor thing. How horrible it would be.

Would you really want to have sex with a woman in the third trimester? She's got what amounts to a basketball for a stomach, doesn't sound to enticing to me. But, whatever floats your boat Emo =P

I thought I could trust you!!!





*runs off crying*

Haha! I <3 Chimi the former virgin girl!

lol this thread is awesome, I saw stars wars when it came out at midnight cause my friend got us tickets and it was awesome. it was just cool to be like watching the last star wars movie with everyone cheering and stuff. I thought it was really good and the part where anakin starts going to the darkside is so cool and the battle at the end has u like on the edge of ur seat the whole time heh. sounds dorky but i really liked it and its kinda sad at the end. but ya i would recommend it to everyone! and common Harry potter vs starwars.. all i gotta say is lightsabers and the force ftw.

Sunday Bro. Lets get some people together and go see it. Pick a time so we can get ticketts early.

8.5/10

Not dark enough imo, but still a great attempt. There was to much comedy, like battle droids talking all this stupid crap... cmon.

And to be honest i dont think that anikin and padmy had good on screen chemisty =/ (they tried though)


But hey i still lovedit for the most part =)

wtf are you guys talking about (sidd especially)....who the fuck are all those poeple? I recognize vader, but uh...who the hell are all those people? WTF is a Q? im so confused. Are we talking starwars (nerd movie #1) or some other nerd movie? inform me. Now

kthx

<3

/boggle

WTF are you talking about? I hit it the day before both my daughters where born. Guess you can say I knocked them loose.

But back to the topic.. childberth aint so bad, they gave my wife some wicked drugs and she was in lala-land. The next serveral days where hell as her body recovered. Like to see that depicted in the movie..

what pregnant girls can be hot...

First off, I am a man. I dont care if she looks like she has a basket ball in her stomach. If its my wife and my child, what could be more beautiful then that? Second, the 5-6 days when my girl is on her period are bad enough, I dont think I could last 30 days with out sex, I would go crazy.

Also I could be wrong, but I thought that women wernt supose to have sex in their third trimester... but if I am wrong, sweet! Also I have to agree, pregent women can defentlly be hot!

<3

Tonight, saterday, 6:45!!!!

Wake up and answer your phone damn it!

also go order your ticket online.

They can, but only in certain positions (obviously), and you should refrain from rough sex. =P

nice! I can live with out the rough sex as long as there is sex.

Also back on topic I saw the movie tonight. It was great. I would give it a 8.5 / 10 ! Defentlly worth the wait and it had everything it needed. I just wish they showed anikin kill the younglings and had the droids act less goofy. I will problly have to see it again.

just stick it in her butt and when she complains about the pain, just have her compare that pain to the pain of giving birth and see which one wins.

Yeah I liked it a lot. Especially the ending it just sets the whole motion set for the next movies, its great makes me want to go watch them again.

Sorry i missed MC guys.

not really a backdoor man here... I would problly have to be drunk and accidentlly pick the wrong hole.

4.5 / 10

Nice special effects. ( as always).

Kinda boring story (since nothing unexpected happens in the entire film).

Stupid conversations.

Horrible camera. (Well it's more the directors fault here. Closeup on every single person that speaks in the entire movie ... cmon we dont live in the 50's)

Sexy Natalie Portman -.-

I hate the droid dialog. I swear R2-D2 is the BEST droid in the movies and has the greatest lines of them all. Although I'm not sure how I feel about him being spring-loaded like a poptart into the fighters.

I think it could have been a LOT darker, especially without the cutsie crap thrown in. Not enough wookies, for the 5 minutes of screentime they got. And I cringed at the tarzan yell. At least some children got killed, that was cool.

I hate you Lucas. Hans shot first.

And to you women: You try making 50,000,000 sperm a day!

Well I finally saw it last night. I wish I hadn't read the book first. It made my expectations way to high

I really suggest reading hte book tho. Its so much darker, the dialogue is better, as the movie leaves alot out. The book makes Anakins struggle between good and bad so much more epic. And the movie just doesn't show the acting for that struggle until the very end during the Anakin/Obi-wan duel.

The opening sequence was badass, but Obi-wans acting is dull till the end as well. I dunno, I just thinkt he emotions and dialogue could have been portrayed alot better. That in itself would have made this movie soooo much better.

They left out so many plot holes. Like the Council plotting behind Anakins back to make him Palpatines assistant so he could spy, and Obi-wan arguing over and over not to do it and that he didn't wanna betray Anakin. A whole side plot not shown was Obi-wans own epic struggle to not betray and lie to anakin, and his love and brotherlike bond with Anakin, and the eventual struggle to accept that as a jedi you have to throw all bonds aside, when he had to kill Anakin. That just wasnt shown at all, and was a major storyline left out.

SO, yea, I give it a 7/10, if the parts I said had been shown better, It woulda got a 9/10 for sure.

But oh well, time to start re-reading hte HP novels so I will be fresh when the new book comes out in 2 months

The last 3 months of pregnacy is awsome IMO. You feel your child move constantly, and my babys mamma always wanted to have sex the last 2 months of her pregnacys. It's the 6 weeks after birth thats a killer.